Peekaboo! is my next Halloween cake with lots of delicious eyeballs and a charade inside!

I wanted to prepare something really special for our family’s Halloween party.

*Disclaimer: This tutorial contains affiliate links.*

Like last year, I served the Baby Foot Appetizer but the cake had to be something new. Just a few weeks ago I made the gingerbread Zombie Pumpkin Cake that was a huge success, so the bar was pretty high. I’d been wanting to make a cake with eyeballs popping out for some time and the idea finally grew into making eyeballs under the “skin” and some more eyeballs on the top of the cake. And then I had an idea for a charade!

The base of the cake is my favorite non-baked cake with blended strawberries which give the cake pinkish color which, in this context, is kind of fleshy. As a fondant, I used Smartflex which I’m not sure is accessible internationally, so I would probably recommend the Wilton White Chocolate flavoured fondant as an alternative.

The eyes inside the cake are made from fresh cheese and those on top of the cake are made from tempered white chocolate.

If you’d like to see more of my Halloween recipes, they are right here.

Table of Contents

Supplies

Cake

350 g/12 oz of small fluffy biscuits of any kind
300 g/10.5 oz of strawberries
400 g/14 oz of sour cream or white yoghurt
500 g/17.5 oz of fresh cheese
powder sugar
springform, diameter 24 – 26 cm/10 – I have this one

Eyes inside the cake

Prepare the cheese-gelatine eyes with this tutorial. You’ll need only three eyeballs so use just half of the ingredients

Chocolate eyeballs – 10 pcs

200 g/7 oz of white chocolate
gel food colorant: black, green (or any other for the iris), red
half-sphere mold
thin brush

Charade

10 small paper stripes
pencil

Decoration

500 g/17.5 oz of Wilton White Chocolate flavoured fondant
gel food colorant: red, green
raspberry marmalade (or another that’s red)
juice from 1 lemon
flat brush
toothpick or another pointy tool
knife
fondant rolling pin
rolling mat

Other

A cake stand will bring the cake presentation to the next level

Peekaboo! – Halloween Cake Tutorial

No bake cake

Blend the strawberries completely smooth and combine with fresh cheese, sour cream/white yoghurt and sugar.

First, cover the bottom of the springform with biscuits, then cover the biscuits with the strawberry-cheese mixture.

Continue alternating the layers until the springform is full.

The last layer should be the liquid one. Keep the cake in the fridge overnight.

Take the side of the springform off and the cake should be solid now.

Cheese Eyeballs

Use this tutorial to prepare 3 eyeballs (half of the ingredients).

Scoop out some cake in three places to make a hole for each eyeball.

Place the eyeballs.

You can put some of the cake you just scooped out back and around the eyeballs.

Decorating

Add some red and green food colorant into the fondant. You don’t need to work it in perfectly, the color doesn’t need to be homogenous. If the fondant’s too sticky after you’ve added the colorant, incorporate some corn starch or powder sugar in it. Cut off a small piece of the fondant and put it aside for later.

Roll out the fondant to be about 3 millimeters thick.

Place the fondant on the cake and press a little around it. I liked the way the fondant hang over the edge of the cake stand, so I didn’t cut it off.

Make a small cut close to an eyeball.

Insert the knife and cut an opening for the eyeball from the inside and pushing out.

Make openings for all three eyeballs.

Cuts

Make some more cuts in the cake in the same way.

That’s how you make the “injuries” on the cake.

Take that piece of fondant you left aside for later. Add some red and maybe black if you like it darker.

Roll out two very thin stripes and then twist them around each other in a spiral.

Use a toothpick or another pointy tool to cut small holes around each cut.

There should be several holes on each side. Fill the cuts with marmalade.

Cut the “thread” you just made in smaller pieces and push each end in a hole.

You can place the thread across the cut in any way you want. I was going for a sloppy hobby-surgeon look, so my stitching is very irregular.

And now the cake is ready for some more color.

Adding color

Mix green and red food colorant to make brown and mix it with the lemon juice. Brush the whole cake with the brown color.

Chocolate Eyeballs and Charade

Melt half of the white chocolate in a water bath. Chop the other half. When the chocolate is melted, take it off the stove and mix in the chopped chocolate and stir until this is also melted. Use a teaspoon to put some chocolate into each half-sphere mold and “brush” it all over the mold with the same spoon. The chocolate will run back to the center, so you have to do this for a while until you see that there’s enough chocolate on the walls.

Let the chocolate set in the fridge and then take the half-spheres out of the mold.

Use a small brush to pain the iris and pupils.

Then use the toothpick to paint some veins.

And now I’m going to tell you about the charade. Each eyeball sitting on the top of the cake will hide a paper with a famous horror movie cake and the guests have to guess the movie. So write one quote on each paper. Here are some for inspiration: